AECO And Station 2 Natural Gas Prices: A Gradual Return To Normalcy

Value Digger

When it comes to the AECO and Station 2 pricing in Alberta and British Columbia respectively, the third quarter of 2017 was an unexpectedly ugly quarter for the Canadian natural gas producers.

TransCanada Corp. (TRP) operates the NOVA Gas Transmission Ltd. (NGTL) System, the largest and most far-reaching network of natural gas pipelines in Alberta that is also the sole outlet for many producers to transport their gas to markets within the Province. And in Q3 2017, TransCanada was working to maintain and expand the NGTL system capacity in Alberta and British Columbia. Specifically, the 2017 NGTL Expansion Project consists of five separate pipeline loops and two compression stations and the current status of each section is below:

  • Northwest Mainline Loop No. 2: Bear Canyon, Operational

  • Liege Lateral Loop No. 2: Pelican Lake, Operational

  • Kettle River Lateral Loop: Christina River, Operational

  • Northwest Mainline Loop: Boundary Lake, spread 1, Operational

  • Grande Prairie Mainline Loop No. 2: McLeod River, ISD Q3 2017

  • Otter Lake Compressor Station Unit Addition, Q4 2017

  • Alces River Compressor Station, Q4 2017

  • Northwest Mainline Loop: Boundary Lake, spread 2, ISD Q2 2018

This project is part of the ongoing C$5.1 billion near-term capital program for the NGTL System further enhancing TransCanada's ability to meet the needs of its customers for safe, reliable and competitive gas transmission infrastructure, led to service reductions pushing AECO prices at extremely low prices (under C$1/GJ) during the third quarter and in October 2017, as illustrated below:

Actually, according to the chart above, natural gas price at Alberta’s AECO pricing hub dropped to negative 15 cents per GJ on some days last October. And negative AECO pricing isn't an everyday thing. Actually, AECO price has never been in negative territory over the last 20 years.

As a result, many natural gas producers have had to shut in production at some of their wells in response to unprecedented drop in gas prices at AECO and Station 2 hubs to avoid selling their molecules for virtually nothing in the spot market.

Curently, the 2017 NGTL Expansion Project is almost complete and most sections of the project have already been in-service as mentioned above, which has helped alleviate the pricing issues in the AECO market. As such, the AECO price has returned above C$2/GJ since Nov. 1, as illustrated below:

And the good news is set to continue for the natural gas producers in Alberta.

The Dawn Hub in Ontario is Canada's largest integrated natural gas storage facility and an integral part of North America's gas infrastructure. Over 100 companies actively buy and sell natural gas at Dawn making it the second-most physically traded hub in North America.

And last September, the National Energy Board approved the new toll agreement between TRP and the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers. As a result, shippers under the deal will transport 1.5 Bcf/d to the Dawn hub in Ontario, based on a single toll rate of $0.77/GJ. Actually, the deal grants a 46% discount for 10 years, down to C$0.77/GJ (65 cents/MMBtu) to 23 producers that bought shipping contracts for 1.4 Bcf/d.

Thanks also to this development, Ontario becomes the centre of a battle between Western Canadian producers and Appalachian producers, given that the competing Rover Pipeline by Energy Transfer Partners LP (ETP) will be in full service in the first half of 2018 delivering gas to Ontario from Pennsylvania. However, it must be noted that the majority of the Rover Pipeline will be utilized by customers on the U.S. segments of the pipeline, and only the volume not consumed in the U.S. will be transported to the Union Gas Hub in Canada, where it will be traded on the open market for consumption either back in the United States or to customers in Canada.

And what about the Station 2 price? Well, the Station 2 price hasn't yet returned to normalcy but still hovers under C$2/GJ because there is one more thing underpinning Stn 2 daily prices lagging AECO. Another pipeline network, the T- South system in British Columbia is still below full capacity. The original forecast chart had capacity coming up to full on Nov. 6th, but it slipped to the 8th.

The T-South system belongs to Westcoast Energy, a company owned by Spectra Energy (SE) that was acquired by Enbridge (ENB) in late 2016. Westcoast Energy announced three pipeline expansion proposal projects (Jackfish, High Pine and Wyndwood) in 2016 with completion date in late 2017, as shown here. And you can find more information about these projects along with the map here.

Therefore, the key reason why the Station 2 pricing remains weak is that Westcoast Energy has completed only the first half of the High Pine Expansion thus far, so the 240 mmcfd expansion has been completed on the Fort Nelson Mainline to Stn 2, but the matching capacity to Sunset and off on TCPL will not be ready before year end. This means that Painted Pony (PONY.T, PDPYF) can flow the incremental 240 mmcfd to Stn 2 but no further, which is currently impacting the market and Station 2 daily prices.

However, after talking with many industry participants, I draw the conclusion that Stn 2 will return to normal supply and demand-based pricing by early 2018 upon completion of the matching capacity to Sunset and off on TCPL. Historically, the Station 2 price was always around Sumas less transportation costs of approximately C$0.50/mcf.

If you want to be ahead of the crowd generating unrivaled returns that often exceed 100%, consider subscribing to "The Knowledgeable Investor" by Value Digger, the insightful Newsletter where you will discover unknown and underfollowed companies that are potential multi-baggers along with high-yield dividend stocks (yields above 7%).

Our picks are debt-free or low leverage stocks with catalysts. And Value Digger has more than 10,000 followers on Seeking Alpha while also being ranked in the TOP-100 on out of over 6,000 financial bloggers and analysts worldwide.

As such, we are confident that this subscription (just $99 for 6 months, a limited-time offer) will pay for itself many times over thanks to our proven track record, our almost 30 years of experience in the stock markets and our painstakingly selected picks from a wide variety of sectors.

Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed here are solely my opinion and should not be construed in any way, shape, or form as a formal investment recommendation. Value Digger does not accept any liability for any loss or damage whatsoever caused in reliance upon such information. Investors are advised that the material contained herein should be used solely for informational purposes. Investors are reminded that before making any securities and/or derivatives transaction, you should perform your own due diligence. Investors should also consider consulting with their broker and/or a financial adviser before making any investment decisions.

Comments (2)
No. 1-2
Value Digger
Value Digger


Good catch, LAlberti. Thank you for the comment. TRP's project will significantly improve the nat gas price in Station 2 by the end of 2018 narrowing the current gap with AECO.


A few days ago, TransCanada's executive vice-president and president Karl Johannson, , Canada and Mexico natural gas pipelines and energy, told the company’s investor day:

"Some gas from Western Canada has already moved to the LNG export market on the Gulf Coast, although not on the TransCanada system, but I think we can compete with any other system out there so if our producers want to do that, we can provide that for them.” "...we can actually move a unit of northeast B.C. gas into Mexico City once we get Sur de Texas fully built out which should be about a year from now.”